Bright Eyes having the same problem at a different school with about another 20lbs. Her card's info says: My Chubbiest Pony Bright Eyes LIGHT / Chubbiest Pony / Level 6 / ATK 0 / DEF 2800 You cannot Normal Summon or Set this card unless you Tribute 1 “My Chubbier Pony Bright Eyes” first. This card cannot be destroyed by battle(with damage calculation). You can activate these effects during either player’s turn:-Negate an attack of a monster that would target a Chubbier Pony or Chubbiest Pony-Type monster you control. - Negate the activation of a card effect your opponent controls that targets a Chubbier Pony or Chubbiest Pony-Type monster you control and destroy it. Rare