Welcome to Inkbunny...
Allowed ratings
To view member-only content, create an account. ( Hide )
fourpundo

Archie Sonic

Reading through it for the first time, up to issue 197, so over halfway.

Holy crap, why is it so dramatic? There's waaaay too much Royalty in it, its really not as good as I thought, which is disappointing, because I grew up knowing about the comic, but never being able to read it, until now, and it just doesn't amount to much besides convoluted multiverse characters, royal inheritance/council drama, relationship drama, stories written to coincide with the games but not having enough to work with and only using a tiny amount, and constant "truces" with betrayals. I talked about the high stakes in IDW, and thought the Egg Grapes part had a similar level of "he finally did it, he caught everyone", but it gets fixed within an issue. If IDW has high stakes, Archie had high stakes that never amount to much. I'm still gonna finish it, I'm committed to seeing it through, like I was with finishing 06, these are just my thoughts. The good heroic stuff is still a ton of fun though.

Edit: Forgot to add how weird the choices made by the council are "hey lets toss these folks in prison for breaking the rules... you know, the ones who've fought for our freedom since they were 8 like some sorta 'Freedom Fighters'??"
Viewed: 33 times
Added: 4 years, 4 months ago
 
Paleumi
4 years, 4 months ago
i never had a chance to read through the comics :'(
Lex
Lex
4 years, 4 months ago
I've never read them, but I have perused summaries of issues and entire arcs, and seen some of the atrocious character designs. I'm sure there are exceptions, but the whole thing comes off as overly melodramatic and silly. The IDW reboot seems like it was desperately needed.

Also that stupid thing Archie comics do with the asterisks pointing to issue reference panels just irritates me.
fourpundo
4 years, 4 months ago
I do like the IDW comic more, even if I have some problems with it too. I know they're establishing a lot right now, and that explains why some characters are so "aggressively themselves" like Shadow is waaaaaaaaay too trope-y. The world is also new and fresh, no forced shipping, just the characters being themselves in a new environment. the Archie comic's "Acorn Kingdom/returning the Royals to the throne/not really here's a council instead" thing doomed it from an early point, because a ton of the issues and drama come from just that.
Gaoru
4 years, 4 months ago
It's because the entire archie series is fan fiction tripe. It was so garb-o
Worst comic ever. I wish I could get back all the wasted hours I spent reading that shit growing up
fourpundo
4 years, 4 months ago
I like the later art, after issue 159. The small moments in between are also nice, even if they don't last. I can sum up the entire story though: Character comes to power, minor character makes a deal with them, minor character betrays them, rinse and repeat. That's it, that's all 200+ issues of Archie Sonic.
Gaoru
4 years, 4 months ago
Yeah that's pretty much archie comic's story structure in a nutshell. It's nice you found little things to like about it but even the art was atrocious and the stories just made me gag.
joykill
4 years, 4 months ago
Archie's sonic was telling stories when we didn't have any games to work off of. when i was reading there we were in the dry spell between sonic 3 and adventures. it was pretty much SatAM, which wasn't really like the games anyway.  it wasn't great but it was all we got.
fourpundo
4 years, 4 months ago
It was pretty high quality considering the lack of story in earlier games and the amount of time between them after. It might be that I'm reading it all in one go and its coming off as "same-y" with it's story telling.
BlackFlash09
4 years, 3 months ago
Fair warning, I'm about to rant a little...

Personally, my biggest beef with the Archie series was that it focused more on Sally, as well as her relationship with Sonic, more than the title character.  If you were a girl who wasn't Sally or Julie-Su, you'd get screwed over in terms of romance.  In fact, there was too much focus on pairings.  It would've been interesting to see Sonic and Knuckles paired with other women, instead of always returning to the status quo.
fourpundo
4 years, 3 months ago
Hadn't thought of that, but you're right, the further into the series you get the more its either about pairings or Sally's family/royal inheritance being a burden
BlackFlash09
4 years, 3 months ago
I couldn't had said it better myself...
CTS101
3 years, 8 months ago
They took the sonic satam characters and storyline but added heavy stupidity, melodrama, will they wont they get together relationships, retcons, recolors of other characters, worse writing, more retcons, ken penders, even more retcons, shitty art at times, ken fucking penders, and just....

sigh. satam wasn’t perfect but i still loved it. the comic? barf.
fourpundo
3 years, 8 months ago
its weird having grown up seeing these comics in store, but never being able to buy them, just imagining them being great, growing up to finally read them, and finding out they've got less good than bad.
CTS101
3 years, 8 months ago
As far as videogame comics went in America there weren’t many choices. In fact this was the longest running comic based on a videogame? 25 years i think.

There was a short lived street fighter comic by malibu comics was.... strange... they did mortal kombat as well.

I really felt they butchered Sally Acorn in the comic. In the show she was the lead female but Sonic was most important and Bunnie Rabbot still got plenty of screen time.
fourpundo
3 years, 8 months ago
They were more concerned with the on-off Sonic/Sally relationship to really develop her past "she's his love interest... sorta, but also look she still does things"
New Comment:
Move reply box to top
Log in or create an account to comment.